In This Week's Issue
Hi Subscriber! Thanks for being here. Here is a helpful link to the entire Front of the Check Archive. Go back and see what’s useful. It’s all yours. https://www.frontofthecheck.com/archive
“Focus on innovating at value, not positioning against competitors” W. Chan Kim
Featured Story
Use a Strategy Canvas to Chart Your Next Career
What if you stopped competing altogether?
Sherman Mohr | INSEAD Blue Ocean Strategy Certified Practitioner and Over 50 Pro
We’re intentionally leaving this here for another week.
Here is how most of us begin the next chapter.
We find twenty postings that look like the last job. We tune the résumé to the keywords or we use some AI proof terminology in hopes we get past the resume eliminating technologies. Then we line up against three hundred applicants, many younger, most cheaper, few of whom remember fax machines, and compete on title, pedigree, availability, and price.
Then we wonder why the water feels so crowded.
INSEAD professors W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne have a name for this. They call it a red ocean: a known market where rivals fight over a fixed pie until the water turns red. The alternative is a blue ocean, uncontested market space where demand is created rather than fought over, and the competition becomes irrelevant because nobody else has drawn the map yet.
Kim and Mauborgne wrote about companies: Cirque du Soleil, Nintendo's Wii, a modest Australian winery called Casella. Nothing in Blue Ocean Strategy or Blue Ocean Shift was written about your career. All of it applies.
The red ocean seems to want to drown us.
Start with the scoreboard. The Bureau of Labor Statistics' most recent displaced-worker survey found that among long-tenured workers who lost jobs between 2023 and 2025, 72.9% of those aged 25 to 54 were reemployed. For ages 55 to 64, the figure was 57.3%. And among everyone who landed full-time work again, only about half earned as much as before.
That is just data. It is not a verdict. It doesn't say you lack value. It says that when you present your value on the same terms as everyone else, buyers compare you on factors that quietly favor a different profile, lower cost, longer runway, newer credentials. You are playing an away game, on their field, with their referee.
Now look at what happens off that field. Economists Katharine Abraham, Brad Hershbein, and Susan Houseman found that self-employment rises markedly with age, and that roughly one in four independent contractors over fifty works for a former employer. Read that twice. The first buyer of your expertise is often the organization that already watched you deliver it.
“The value was never the problem. The packaging was.”
Kim and Mauborgne's own research points the same direction. Studying 108 business launches, they found 86% were line extensions, incremental moves inside existing markets, producing 62% of revenue but only 39% of profit. The 14% that created new market space delivered 38% of revenue and 61% of profit. Most effort goes to the incremental move. Most of the money lives in the creative one. "Another job like my last one" is a line extension.
The tool: one page, two lines, and nowhere to hide
The central instrument in the Blue Ocean toolkit is the strategy canvas, and its beauty is that it fits on a napkin.
The horizontal axis lists the factors a market competes on. This is what buyers evaluate and sellers invest in. The vertical axis shows how much of each factor an offering delivers, from low to high. Plot the points, connect them, and you have a value curve: a picture of a strategy.
A significant point. When we plot most industries and the competitors' curves look nearly identical. Converging curves are the signature of a commodity market, where differentiation dies and price decides.
Draw the canvas for the senior-executive job market and you will likely find thirty years flattened into a line almost indistinguishable from the next candidate's: high on experience, high on title, high on salary, high on the demand for a full-time role. Same shape, bigger number on cost. That's not a strategy. That's a bid.
Which is why the canvas is an ideation tool, not just a diagnostic. It makes your strategy visible, and anything visible can be redrawn. Ideation here isn't waiting at a whiteboard for inspiration. It's deliberately bending a curve.
Five moves to draw your blue ocean
1. Draw the as-is canvas, honestly. List eight to ten factors buyers in your current lane use to choose. Use their language, not yours. "risk of a bad hire," not "leadership presence." Plot three curves: 1) you as a full-time candidate, 2) the alternative buyers usually choose instead, and 3) doing nothing. Most people discover they've been competing hardest on the factors where they're weakest.
2. Go find the noncustomers. Kim and Mauborgne describe three tiers outside any market: soon-to-be noncustomers who buy reluctantly, refusing noncustomers who consciously chose against the market, and unexplored noncustomers who never considered it. For an experienced operator, the refusing tier is often gold, the $30 million family company that would never pay $275,000 for a chief operating officer and won't hire consultants because "they're expensive and leave a binder." These buyers have the problem and have rejected every existing solution. That isn't a dead end. It's a door nobody has walked through. The soon-to-be noncustomers are those companies that have an immediate problem, it has to be solved. The unexplored noncustomers are perhaps the companies that never dreamed they could hire someone who delivered the outcomes or results you delivered.
3. Run the six paths. The framework offers six lenses for redrawing market boundaries. Translated for a career:
Look across alternative industries and ask what else solves the buyer's problem? Is it software, a nephew, or doing nothing?
Look across strategic groups and ask is it a full-time hire, fractional executive, big firm, or solo advisor?
Look across the chain of buyers and ask is it the CEO, the CFO, the board, or the founder's spouse?
Look across complementary offerings, what happens before and after your work? Who benefitted? A lender, the succession attorney, the heirs?
Look across functional and emotional appeal. Are you selling spreadsheets when the buyer is purchasing a night's sleep, i.e. peace of mind?
Look across time. Are there irreversible trends, like a generation of owners heading for the exit, or AI disruption? What will change what buyers need?
4. Apply the Four Actions Framework. This is where the canvas earns its keep. For each factor, ask: which should be eliminated? Reduced well below the standard? Raised well above it? Created that the market has never offered? Eliminating and reducing lowers the buyer's cost; raising and creating lifts their value. Doing both at once is what Kim and Mauborgne call value innovation. For the over-fifty professional it carries a bonus: you eliminate the factors where age counts against you and raise the ones where decades are an unfair advantage.
5. Redraw the curve and test it. A strong blue ocean curve has three hallmarks: focus (it doesn't try to be high on everything), divergence (its shape looks nothing like the competition's), and a compelling tagline. If you can't state your offer in one sentence a stranger would repeat, you don't have a strategy yet. You have a wish.
A canvas in action
Consider a composite drawn from someone who’s gone through the process. Call her Dana: 58, a former vice president of operations at a regional food distributor, a strong résumé, and a long list of polite rejections for COO roles.
Her as-is canvas was a near-perfect copy of every other senior candidate's. So she went looking for refusing noncustomers and found them: family-owned distributors and manufacturers between $15 million and $60 million in revenue, facing an ownership handoff. They had never hired a COO. They distrusted consultants. They had an expensive problem, a second generation inheriting a business that ran on the founder's memory, and no solution they'd buy.
Her Four Actions grid:
Her tagline: A COO for the handoff — without hiring a COO.
Figure: Dana's value curve diverges where the market converges — low on the factors that tax age, high on the ones that reward it. Scores are illustrative.
Notice what changed. Dana didn't become a better candidate. She stopped being a candidate. The factors where age penalized, her cost, full-time runway, credential recency dropped to near zero. The factors where three decades are a moat, judgment, pattern recognition, calm in a crisis, and a contact list full of people who answer, went to the top of the chart.
It's the same move Casella made with [yellow tail]. Rather than out-wine the wine industry on vintage, aging, and vocabulary, it eliminated the complexity and intimidation and created something easy and fun for people who had been drinking beer. It didn't win the competition. It made the competition beside the point.
Why this helps the after fifty reframe
A 35-year-old can fight in the red ocean for a decade and still have a career. You probably can't, and you shouldn't want to. The factors the conventional job market weights most heavily are disproportionately the ones where age is a tax. The factors a blue ocean is built on, judgment, networks, earned trust, and the scar tissue of having seen this movie before, are compounding assets no one under forty can buy at any price.
The canvas is how you choose the battlefield instead of accepting the one you were assigned. That is the whole game.
The cost of staying in that red ocean of bloody competition
Staying in the red ocean doesn't fail dramatically. It fails slowly: a search that stretches from four months to fourteen, a salary "adjustment" you accept because the alternative is more silence, a gradual drift from executive to applicant. Every month spent competing on the market's terms is a month your real differentiators sit idle and depreciate.
The blue ocean costs something too. A weekend of honest work and the nerve to look visibly different. That's the cheaper price.
If you want help constructing your Blue Ocean Career Canvas, I’m here to help. Reach out at https://shermanmohr.com
Join us in community? Join the Second Act Advantage Community by visiting us each Monday. No agenda, some structure, some accountability. We’ll start October 5th at 12:30 Eastern with a simple three question guideline.
1) What do you have planned this week?
2) What are your hurdles?
3) What did you accomplish over the last week?
Here is the link: Second Act Community Call
Monday, October 5 · 12:30 – 1:00pm
Time zone: America/New York
Google Meet joining info
Video call link: https://meet.google.com/xpk-xbxe-pyy
If you need assistance or want to discuss anything above, schedule a call.
Thanks to our sponsor. Nokbox: A system designed to keep life organized, even when things get chaotic. NOK stands for Next of Kin, and NOKBOX help you organize important documents, accounts, possessions, and estate details so your next of kin knows exactly what to do in something happens.
But it’s not just for the future. NOKBOX gives you peace of mind now by keeping everything in one organized place, saving time, reducing stress, and making it easy to find what you need when you need it.
Check them out below and invest in a NOKBOX for you and your family.
A system to stay consistent even when life gets chaotic.
Over 50 Pro Featured Resources of the Week:
These frameworks and diagnostic tools operationalize the shift from competing in saturated markets to designing uncontested career paths.
Conceptboard: Blue Ocean Strategy Template and Guide
This visual workspace walks through building a Strategy Canvas to discover new value curves. It forces users to step into the buyer's perspective to map out which factors the market truly values versus what traditional candidates are blindly competing on.
100 Tasks: Build an ERRC Grid
A practical guide to the Eliminate-Reduce-Raise-Create framework. This grid helps candidates stop treating their careers like feature wish lists and start structurally eliminating factors that no longer serve them—like competing on credential recency—to fund the areas where they deliver massive value.
Vibe: Four Actions Framework Guide & Template (2026)
An updated deep dive into strategic trade-off thinking. It challenges the instinct to default to "adding more features" (or packing more bullets onto a resume) and provides a structured process for pressure-testing ideas with "noncustomers" to reconstruct what buyers are actually purchasing.
Corporate Finance Institute: Blue Ocean Strategy Explained
While framed for corporate environments, this breakdown sharply contrasts Red vs. Blue Ocean strategies. It highlights how fighting in saturated, mature markets inevitably forces competitors to compete on price and incremental additions, whereas value innovation opens entirely new demand.
Blue Ocean Strategy Official: The ERRC Grid
The foundational diagnostic instrument directly from creators W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne. It serves as the authoritative starting point for forcing leaders—or individual professionals—to identify what their industry takes for granted that should be eliminated entirely.
Favorite Stories of the Week:
Instead of competing on the red ocean terms of a traditional job search, here are five examples of career reinventions that create uncontested market space. These paths shift the focus away from title and recency, and instead monetize judgment, pattern recognition, and intellectual property.
1. The Fractional Executive (CFO, COO, CMO)
Instead of fighting for a single full-time C-suite role at a large corporation, the executive sells a fraction of their time to small and mid-sized businesses.
The Blue Ocean Move: They eliminate the full-time salary and benefits burden, targeting the "refusing noncustomer"—companies between $10M and $60M that desperately need operational structure but refuse to hire a traditional executive. They raise speed-to-impact and accountability.
Example Link: The Rise Of Fractional Executives
2. The Niche "Encore" Consultant
Rather than seeking a generic VP title, a professional packages their highest-value transferable skill into a fixed-scope solution for a highly specific problem (e.g., succession handoffs or post-merger integration).
The Blue Ocean Move: They reduce the resume gauntlet and corporate politics, abandoning broad job descriptions. They create a focused engagement with a defined finish line, built entirely on their accumulated scar tissue.
Example Link: Encore Careers: Independent Consulting
3. The IP-Monetizing Digital Solopreneur
A professional takes a proprietary framework or specialized diagnostic tool (like an operational scoring system) they developed over decades and turns it into a scalable digital product, course, or assessment.
The Blue Ocean Move: They eliminate hourly billing, bespoke proposals, and the requirement to be "in the room." They target the "unexplored noncustomer"—smaller businesses that would never hire them as a consultant but will eagerly buy their intellectual property to self-diagnose their operations.
Example Link: Encore Careers: Expertise-Based Business
4. The Specialized Executive Coach
Taking the friction they experienced in their own corporate trajectory (e.g., navigating visibility, leadership transitions, or team conflict), a former executive builds a coaching practice specifically for others hitting that exact wall.
The Blue Ocean Move: They stop competing for the next rung on the corporate ladder and instead target "soon-to-be noncustomers"—professionals currently struggling within their own red oceans. They raise empathy, shared experience, and actionable transition playbooks.
Example Link: Work From The Inside Out (Susan Barber Case Study)
5. The Independent Board Member or Strategic Advisor
Instead of competing for an operational day-to-day role, an experienced leader transitions to offering governance and strategic oversight to growing family businesses, startups, or nonprofits.
The Blue Ocean Move: They eliminate the daily operational grind and "time to onboard," stepping completely out of the traditional applicant pool. They raise the value of their high-level judgment and extensive contact list—assets younger candidates cannot match.
Example Link: Encore Careers: Mission-Driven Advisory Work
These moves all share the same underlying mechanics: they stop presenting as candidates and start presenting as specialized solutions.
To map how this shift alters the competitive landscape, this strategy canvas visualizes how the value curve of a traditional job search diverges from a fractional blue ocean path: Traditional Candidate in gray, Blue Ocean Over 50 Candidate in Blue.
In Case You Missed It
You’re doing $15 tasks with $150 talent. Need help with spreadsheets, social media posting, article creation and posting, LinkedIn connecting, etc? How does reliable help for $5.00 hourly sound?
A free seven day challenge program that gets you reconnected with your network. Less than 10 minutes a day. Click Here
Interested in business coaching, consulting, or Fractional work? Over50Pros offers a free research report on the state of the business coaching, consulting, and Fractional Executive industries. Also, a helpful Industry Entry Decision Guide. Both resources are free with an email address. https://over50pros.com
Final Thoughts
Imagine being the only one of you?
Ha! In fact, that is the case. you don’t need a strategy canvas to prove it. It’s just a tool to make it more obvious to yourself and others.
I highly encourage you to go through the exercise. I’m in touch with so many people who want out of their current situations and just feel stuck.
I am convinced of the old truism, “What you think about, is what you talk about, is what you bring about.”
How do you change the thought? Change the input. If you need a path, do a strategy canvas on the person you are now, compared to the person you wish to become. With the value curve you uncover, you’ll know more about what to work on to bring about the change you desire in your life.
And as always, if you need help with anything related to topics in the newsletter or transition over 50 years old, schedule a call.
Please click below and tell me what you like or dislike about the Front of the Check newsletter and how I may deliver more value to you! You are my growing community and I want your feedback. I’ll Venmo or Zelle you $5 for two minutes of feedback.
Coming Next Week: A new line of thinking is called for in today’s age of AI.
Experience Leads to Outcomes